Saturday, 29 May 2010

Rene Descartes

Rene Descartes (1596-1650) is often described as the founder of modern philosophy. Born at the French town of La Haye, between Tours and Poitiers, his father was one of the local landed gentry. The boy was sent to boarding school, meaning the Jesuit college of La Fleche, where he stayed for eight years. The Jesuit curriculum encompassed the classical humanities and the prevalent Aristotelian Scholasticism. Following the wishes of his father, in 1616 Descartes took a degree in law at the University of Poitiers, but did not pursue the paternal profession. Instead he reacted to academic studies, rejecting much of what he had been taught.

In 1618 Descartes opted for military enlistment, like many others of his social class at this time of religious wars. Moving to the Netherlands, he became a soldier or engineer in the army of Prince Maurice of Nassau. While stationed at Breda that year, he formed a friendship with the Dutch mathematician Isaac Beeckman (1588-1637). Some extant letters of Descartes reveal that this scientist “roused me from my state of indolence and reawakened the learning which by then had almost disappeared from my memory.” Quotation from J. Cottingham, “Descartes” (93-134) in R. Monk and F. Raphael, eds., The Great Philosophers (London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson, 2000), p. 100. Descartes also referred in those epistles to his project of a new science providing “a general solution of all possible equations involving any sort of quantity” (ibid., p. 99).

Moving to Germany for further military service, in 1619 he gained three vivid dreams that were reported by his seventeenth century biographer Adrien Baillet. One passage reads: “Beginning to interpret the dream while still asleep, he considered that the encyclopaedia signified all the sciences collected together, and that the anthology of poetry indicated philosophy and wisdom combined” (ibid., pp. 101-2). The famous “method of doubt” evidently originated in his belief, rooted in a rather non-logical dream experience, that “he was destined to complete the unfinished ‘encyclopaedia’ of the sciences” (ibid., p. 102).

The dreams inspired him to seek a new method of science and philosophy. Afterwards moving to Paris, and making other journeys, Descartes devoted himself to the private study of various sciences, and commenced to write an unfinished treatise on method (Rules for the Direction of the Mind). He sold his ancestral property to secure (via bonds) a workable income for many years after. In 1629 he moved back to the Netherlands, a country then associated with freedom of expression. He resided there for twenty years, though retaining a habit of being frequently on the move, living in Amsterdam. Leiden, and other places.


Descartes remained a Roman Catholic, though of an avant-garde type. He wanted to show that the “new physics” could explain the world without relying upon the terminology of Scholastic Aristotelianism, a problem which indeed "was so entrenched in the intellectual institutions of Descartes' time that commentators argued that evidence for its truth could be found in the Bible." Quotation from J. Skirry, "Rene Descartes: Overview" (2008), Internet Encyclopaedia of Philosophy.

He composed a treatise on cosmology and mechanistic physics entitled Le Monde (The World), which was ready to go to press in 1633. A problem was encountered. Descartes had utilised Copernican heliocentric theory in his treatise, and he now discovered how Galileo had been condemned that year in Rome for contesting the conventional belief that the earth was the centre of motion. In a mood of caution, Descartes decided not to publish Le Monde. “Indeed, he first decided never to publish anything at all; but the despair did not last” (D. Garber, “Rene Descartes: Life,” Routledge Encyclopaedia of Philosophy).

A few years later, he published in French three scientific essays, the Meteorology, Optics, and Geometry (1637). These accompanied his anonymous Discourse on Method, which was intended as an introduction. The collection became well known. The later Latin work Principia Philosophiae (1644) describes metaphysics, an extending physics, and other sciences. This significant work proved influential amongst scientists (including Isaac Newton), though the physics transpired to be limited in application. Descartes viewed metaphysics as the root of his holistic endeavour to combine philosophy and the sciences.

His two most famous works are Discourse on Method (1637) and the Meditations on First Philosophy (1641). These reveal Descartes as a rationalist who strongly believed in the existence of God, but who at the same time innovated concepts foreign to most theologians.

Descartes is most well known for his theories about the distinction between mind and matter. The most common description of this complexity is "Cartesian dualism." The accompanying "method of doubt" signifies the non-acceptance of anything that can be logically doubted, and for the purpose of finding certainty.

The Cartesian axiom cogito ergo sum (“I think, therefore I am”) was confirming a factor beyond doubt, and serving to elevate the importance of mind and self-consciousness. The argument of Descartes was pitched against the emerging scepticism associated with Michel de Montaigne. Yet like Francis Bacon (entry no. 20), Descartes was also in strong opposition to the official Aristotelian philosophy of the academics, though having a different angle to that of the British empiricist. Nevertheless, Descartes possessed a strong empirical streak. See further my
Rene Descartes, Philosopher and Scientist (2010).

“Descartes claimed that he had taken the doubts of the sceptics further than the sceptics had taken them, and had been able to come out the other side” (B. Williams, introductory essay to J. Cottingham, ed., Descartes: Meditations on First Philosophy, Cambridge University Press, 1996, p. xv).

Descartes was basically remote from the academic milieu, preferring a quiet life away from both career status and social distraction. His citizen status tends to be emphasised by the situation in which he addressed a letter to academics of the Sorbonne, a letter appended to the Meditations. His motive appears to have been that of gaining textbook status in the university.

One commentary says: "The awkwardness of Descartes's seeking the acceptance and use of his Meditations by teachers is amplified by the fact that he was not a teacher himself. Consequently, his seeking 'textbook' status would have very likely been viewed by those Learned Men as being a bit pretentious. He was, it could be said, a freelancer with no academic or political ties to the university.... Although the Meditations seems to have been endorsed by the Sorbonne, it was never adopted as a text for the university." Quotation from K. Smith, "Descartes' Life and Works" (2007), Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy.

The same book subsequently became more famous and more cited than the majority of texts known to the Sorbonne. The freelance citizen philosopher became one of the most influential thinkers in the modern era.

The Dutch Calvinist theologian Gisbertus Voetius (1588-1676) became a major problem during the 1640s, inspiring another academic to publish a lengthy personal attack upon Descartes, who was dogmatically viewed as a route to atheism. Voetius was a professor and became the rector of Utrecht University. Descartes composed the retaliatory Open Letter to Voetius (1643). Voetius subsequently suffered a setback when his accomplice disowned the attack, admitting that Voetius was the cause of the hostility. A later episode involved theological opponents at Leiden University. See further Problems with Calvinist Theologians (2010).

After some hesitation, in 1649 Descartes accepted the invitation from Queen Christina of Sweden to attend her court in Stockholm. She requested him to teach her philosophy, a role entailing an inconvenient hour at five in the morning. For some reason or other, Descartes tragically died. Some accounts state the cause as pneumonia, though poisoning by a hostile Catholic priest has also been suggested. In a letter dated January 1950, Descartes commented: "I desire only peace and quiet, which are benefits that the most powerful monarchs on earth cannot give" (Cottingham, art. cit., p. 105).

See further J. Cottingham et al, The Philosophical Writings of Descartes (3 vols, Cambridge, 1984-91); J. Cottingham, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Descartes (Cambridge, 1992); S. Gaukroger, Descartes: An Intellectual Biography (Oxford, 1995); R. Ariew, Descartes and the Last Scholastics (Ithaca, N.Y., 1999); D. Garber, Descartes Embodied (Cambridge, 2001); J. Broughton, Descartes's Method of Doubt (Princeton, N.J., 2002); S. Gaukroger, Descartes' System of Natural Philosophy (Cambridge, 2002); D. M. Clarke, Descartes: A Biography (Cambridge, 2006); J. Cottingham, Cartesian Reflections (Oxford, 2008).

Kevin R.D. Shepherd
May 29th 2010

ENTRY no. 21

Copyright © 2010 Kevin R. D. Shepherd. All Rights Reserved.